Fort Nathan Hale

Also known as Black Rock Fort, this site was a military fortification during both the Revolutionary War and Civil War. The reconstructed fort sits on the original location where colonial defenders fought British invaders.

Fort Nathan Hale stands as a haunted sentinel on the eastern shore of New Haven Harbor, its layered history spanning nearly four centuries of American military conflict. The site first saw fortifications in 1659 when the New Haven Colony erected earthworks and a battery to defend their harbor. But it was the Revolutionary War that baptized this ground in blood and birthed the spirits that still walk its ramparts today.

On July 5, 1779, British warships under Commodore Sir George Collier darkened the mouth of New Haven Harbor. Major General William Tryon commanded a force of 2,600 men—the 23rd Royal Regiment, Landgrave's Hessian Regiment, and the Tory unit known as "The King's Americans." Against this overwhelming force stood just nineteen patriots under the command of Lieutenant Daniel Bishop (some accounts name Lieutenant Pierpont), perched on the rocky ledge of Black Rock Fort.

For hours, the small militia held back the Redcoats, firing cannon into the British ranks until their ammunition ran dry. Rather than surrender their guns to the enemy, they spiked the cannon barrels, rendering them useless to the invaders. The defenders were captured, the barracks were set ablaze, and Tryon's forces marched into New Haven, where they spent the next two days burning homes, killing patriots, and becoming drunk on local rum. The British invasion left 23 Americans dead, 15 wounded, and 12 captured. When the British finally withdrew, they declared the city "too pretty to burn"—though they had already done considerable damage.

The fort saw action again during the War of 1812, when it was reconstructed with six guns under the second system of US fortifications and renamed Fort Nathan Hale after Connecticut's martyred spy hero. Federal guns kept British warships from entering the harbor. In 1863, concern over Confederate raiders prompted the construction of Fort Nathan Hale II alongside the original fortification—an imposing structure with earthen ramparts, five bombproof bunkers, a moat crossed by drawbridge, and eighteen heavy-caliber guns. Though completed in 1866, this Civil War fort never saw combat.

The spirits, however, have been active for more than a century.

Visitors and paranormal investigators have documented a consistent array of phenomena at Fort Nathan Hale. The most frequently reported are green glowing orbs that float silently across the property, drifting between the reconstructed Revolutionary War fort and the Civil War earthworks. These mysterious lights have been observed for over one hundred years, long before the modern era of ghost hunting. The Cosmic Society of Paranormal Investigation, one of Connecticut's most respected paranormal groups, has documented the location and noted "psychic photos" captured at the fort.

Apparitions of soldiers materialize on the battlements—some in Continental blue, others in Civil War gray—guarding their posts in death as they did in life. The ghosts of the nineteen defenders seem particularly active, their spirits forever locked in that desperate July morning when they stood against impossible odds. Witnesses describe shadowy figures moving across the ramparts, disappearing when approached. Some report seeing full-bodied apparitions that vanish into the walls of the bombproof bunkers.

Unexplained voices echo through the fort's tunnels and earthworks. Visitors hear phantom footsteps on the wooden drawbridge when no one is there. Faint whispers of commands and the distant crack of musket fire drift across the grounds, remnants of battles long past. One visitor on May 9, 2015, captured EVP evidence—a male voice whispering their first name, and in response to the question "what song should I sing?" a spirit clearly replied "La Bamba." A local resident reported: "I go camping there sometimes and go to the beach there most of the time and I've seen and heard voices and the green orb."

Author Garrison Leykam posed the question in his book Haunted New Haven: "What are those unexplained voices trying to tell us at Fort Nathan Hale?" Perhaps they speak of unfinished duty, of men who died defending their harbor and cannot rest while their post remains. The combination of Revolutionary War trauma and Civil War military presence creates what paranormal researchers call a "layered haunting"—soldiers from different eras coexisting in the same space, their energies overlapping across time.

Today, the Fort Nathan Hale Restoration Project maintains the twenty-acre park, and over 7,000 visitors tour the site annually. Both Black Rock Fort and Fort Nathan Hale have been meticulously reconstructed, complete with drawbridge, moat, ramparts, powder magazines, and bombproof bunkers. Every night, volunteers wheel a statue of Nathan Hale into storage to protect it from vandals—but they cannot protect visitors from the spirits that emerge after dark, still standing watch over New Haven Harbor.