Gallows Hill Road

At the corner of Gallows Hill Road and Brookside Place once stood a giant hanging tree where Revolutionary War spies were executed. Though the tree is gone, the site retains its dark energy from centuries of public executions.

At the intersection of Gallows Hill Road and Brookside Place in Cranford, New Jersey, once stood a massive oak tree that served as a gallows during the American Revolution. This elevated location was chosen deliberately—executions on high ground maximized visibility and served as a grim warning to would-be traitors. The tree witnessed the deaths of an estimated ten British spies and sympathizers whose bodies were left swinging as a deterrent to others who might consider betraying the Patriot cause.

The most documented execution at this site was that of James Morgan, an American sentry hanged on January 29, 1782. Morgan had killed the Reverend James Caldwell—known as the "Fighting Parson"—on November 24, 1781, when Caldwell refused to have a package inspected at a checkpoint in Elizabethtown. Reverend Caldwell was a beloved figure who had rallied troops at the Battle of Springfield with his famous cry "Give 'em Watts, boys!" while distributing hymnal pages as musket wadding. His murder was widely suspected to be a British-orchestrated assassination, and Morgan's swift trial at the Presbyterian Church in Westfield resulted in a death sentence. Eight days later, he was marched to Gallows Hill and hanged.

The hanging tree was cut down years ago, but a rusted iron post and concrete remnant where the execution rope was once secured still marks the spot. Since its removal, paranormal activity at this otherwise quiet residential intersection has been regularly reported. Witnesses describe seeing apparitions of Revolutionary War soldiers standing along the roadside, visible from a distance but vanishing as drivers approach. The figures appear to be wearing period military attire and seem frozen in place, as if awaiting their fate.

Cold spots are frequently reported in the immediate area, even during warm summer evenings. Residents and passersby have reported hearing disembodied yelling and shouting, prompting numerous calls to local police—yet officers never find anyone at the scene. Many believe these are the final cries of the condemned, echoing through the centuries as they protested their innocence or called out for mercy.

One visitor described seeing what appeared to be tall bushes swaying in the wind late at night, only to realize upon closer inspection that there were no bushes—just a well-manicured lawn and an overwhelming sense of unease. The movement, they concluded, had no natural explanation.

The intersection sits within what was once the farm of Gideon Ludlow, near a natural spring on what is now Indian Spring Road. Adjacent to the Cranford line, the area connects to Fairview Cemetery, creating a corridor of death and remembrance that spans centuries. Today, Gallows Hill Road remains a local landmark, its very name preserving the memory of colonial justice and the men who met their end here. The spirits of the Revolutionary War condemned are said to remain bound to this crossroads, unable to find peace so far from proper burial grounds.