SpookFinder is on the iPhone. Haunts near you, saved for when there's no signal. Get the app
🪦
Christ Church, Frederica in St. Simons Island, Georgia
Researched Nov 2026

Christ Church, Frederica

St. Simons Island, Georgia · Cemeteries

Photo: Bubba73 / Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Christ_Church,_St._Simons,_GA,_US_(03).jpg) · CC BY-SA 3.0

A young woman who dreaded the dark is said to be buried at Christ Church, Frederica, on St. Simons Island. Her husband promised her a light. He carried a candle to her grave every night until he died, and after that, islanders kept seeing the light anyway.

She was afraid of the dark, so every night, as the daylight faded, her husband brought a candle into their bedroom. The couple lived on St. Simons Island, Georgia, and she's said to be buried in the cemetery at Christ Church, Frederica.

Years later she fell ill. As she neared death, she told her husband she was afraid of being trapped in a dark grave, and he made her a promise. Every night at bedtime, he'd bring a lit candle to her grave. He kept that promise until he died himself.

Then, after his death, as the Atlanta Journal-Constitution told the story in 2017, island residents "were stunned to see the light continue to appear in the cemetery."

The legend puts the burial in the years before the Civil War, and it's been passed around so often that, as the folklore site Southern Spirit Guide puts it, "there are numerous variations." In some of them, her fear came from stories her Caribbean-born nurse told her. She got good at making candles, and some versions say a burn from the wax got infected and that's what killed her so young. Not one version gives a name to her, to her husband or to the nurse. In 2012, Lewis Powell IV went looking for the light for that site and couldn't find anyone reporting it in modern times.

The ground itself is old. Charles Wesley began his American ministry at Frederica in 1736, the year Oglethorpe founded the town. The cemetery holds about 1,600 graves now. The oldest marked stone is from 1803, for a woman named Harriett Ross, who was 26, and there are believed to be burials older than that, possibly some conducted by the Wesleys themselves. The Hazzard family has a vault there too, and in 1838 a fight over a property line ended with Dr. Thomas Fuller Hazzard shooting a man named John Armstrong Wylly. Hazzard was acquitted.

The church standing there now is a memorial of its own, though no version of the candle story ties the two together. Union troops occupied the island during the Civil War, and the families who came back found the first church damaged beyond repair. Anson Dodge rebuilt it starting in 1884 in memory of his first wife, Ellen, who had died in India the year before, at 21, on a trip around the world. It's unpainted heart pine, held together with wooden pegs, and the church says its rafters "resemble an upside-down hull of a ship."

A brick wall runs along Frederica Road now and blocks the view, and spotlights light up the church at night. Some say a flickering light can still be seen, just outside the cemetery walls.

Where it is

6329 Frederica Road

Sources (11)

Last researched Nov 2026

How we research
Open in Google Maps

Something wrong with this place?

More haunted cemeteries in Georgia →