Lake Ronkonkoma

Long Island's largest freshwater lake has a dark reputation — it's been the site of a disproportionate number of drownings, especially of young men. Local legend held it sacred to the Native tribes who lived here, and the folklore around its waters has only grown darker over the years.

The Lady of the Lake is Long Island's most enduring ghost legend. According to the tale, a Native American princess committed suicide in the lake after her warrior lover was killed, and her body was never recovered. She returns annually to claim another male victim, luring young men to watery deaths in revenge. The phantom princess can be seen lamenting along the shore, calling out to potential victims. Locals claim the lake has taken an unusual number of male drowning victims over the decades. Some report seeing a beautiful woman beckoning from the water's surface at night. Whether supernatural curse or dangerous swimming conditions, the lake has earned its deadly reputation.